Webabout 40 masked men overpowered sheriff george shower at the carroll county jail, threw cook into a wagon, drove him to a farm, and hanged him. “half of the town, some. Websmith had been convicted solely on circumstantial evidence, and right from the start, many questioned the verdict. While there may have been military hangings at madison. Roby of the daviess circuit court ordered the sheriff to transport bethea to the jefferson county jail in louisville. While being transferred, bethea made his first. Webwhen the duo arrived back in ashe county, sheriff clark found that the odds were stacking up against banks having a fair trial, so much so that he ultimately. Webinside, written in the black ink of a clerk’s fountain pen in cursive script are the words that sealed the fate of william jackson marion. “he shall be taken by the sheriff. Webat the sentencing, cummin said the verdict was determined by a group of 12 “impartial and conscientious” men who weighed the evidence and confessions of both. Webhe was the first man ever executed in jefferson county. The area of henry evans’s public hanging in august of 1828, per information from one article in 1892, was close to the. Webtheodore smith and thomas faircloth to be hung for shooting faircloth's aunt and uncle while he and smith were robbing their house. Also pictured is sheriff sutton.