Webthe perron family claims that the events of the haunting were authentic. More than that, they continue to be haunted by the ghost of bathsheba thayer, a witch whose spirit still. Webis there any evidence that the real amityville house was haunted? (click to enlarge) the alleged amityville ghost peers out from a doorway on the second floor. The real horror of the amityville. Webthirty miles outside of new york city, nestled in the long island town of amityville, stands the house forever linked to the amityville horror phenomenon. Webeverything you thought you knew about the haunted amityville horror house in new york is wrong. The story goes much deeper. This is the twisted truth. Webed and lorraine warren had been investigating paranormal activity since the early 1950’s. Webit's been more than 45 years since george and kathy lutz fled their house in amityville, long island, claiming it was haunted by evil sprits.
