Attorney's office, southern district of ohio. Webcolumbus, ohio (wcmh) — the first week of former columbus police vice officer andrew mitchell’s murder trial concluded friday after the state rested its case. Webandrew mitchell, 59, pleaded guilty thursday to two counts of depriving individuals of their civil rights while acting under color of law and one count of. Weba new date has been set for the retrial of a former columbus police vice squad officer charged in the death of a woman over four years ago. Webaccording to court documents, andrew mitchell, who was accused of shooting and killing sex worker donna castleberry in 2018, was arrested in march 2019.