I’m kinda new to fnaf and i’m currently reading tse where charlie is a grown woman but for what i know the same charlie emily is the first victim of afton when she was a child.
Simultaneous to this, afton committed his first kill (that we know of) at freddy fazbear’s pizza — his business partner henry’s young daughter, charlotte emily.
Webelizabeth afton was william afton's daughter who, after being abused and neglected by her father, ultimately possesses circus baby after wanting her father's love and attention.